WHAT TO ASK BEFORE HIRING A BRAND OR MARKETING AGENCY (15 QUESTIONS THAT MATTER)
You're in the room — or on the Zoom — with a marketing agency, and they're presenting themselves well. The case studies look impressive. The team seems sharp. The capabilities deck checks all the boxes. And you're trying to figure out whether what you're seeing is the genuine quality of the agency or just the genuine quality of their sales process.
The difference between those two things is enormous. A great sales process can mask mediocre execution. A modest sales process can hide exceptional capability. And evaluating agencies based on their pitches without probing deeper is one of the most expensive mistakes a wellness practice owner can make — typically discovered six months into an engagement, when the polished pitch has turned into disappointing work.
The way to see past the pitch is to ask specific questions designed to surface what the agency actually does, how they actually think, and what working with them will actually be like. Generic questions get generic answers; the agency will pivot back to their pitch and you'll learn nothing new. Specific, probing questions get specific answers — or reveal that the agency can't give specific answers, which is itself diagnostic.
Here are fifteen questions that consistently surface the most important information when evaluating brand and marketing agencies for wellness practices. They're organized by what they reveal: strategic depth, execution quality, relationship dynamics, and category fit. Asked thoughtfully across one or two conversations, they'll give you genuine insight into whether this agency is the right fit for your specific situation.
Questions That Reveal Strategic Depth
1. "How would you approach the first thirty days of working with us, before any execution begins?"
This question reveals whether an agency genuinely values strategic foundation work or just pays lip service to it. The agencies you want to work with will describe a substantive discovery process — stakeholder interviews, competitive research, brand strategy development, audience definition work. They'll describe specific deliverables that emerge from this phase before tactical execution begins. The agencies you want to avoid will describe immediately jumping into "quick wins" or "low-hanging fruit" — which usually translates to running ads or producing content before they understand your business well enough to do either thoughtfully.
The best agencies treat the first thirty days as the most important phase of the engagement. Agencies that minimize this phase or rush past it are revealing their actual priorities.
A subtle variation of this question worth asking: "what specifically would you NOT do in the first thirty days?" The answer is revealing. Strong agencies will be clear about what they avoid — they won't launch campaigns before strategy is defined, won't make tactical recommendations before discovery is complete, won't accept rushed timelines that compromise the foundation. Weak agencies will struggle with this question because they don't actually have disciplined boundaries about what they will and won't do.
2. "How do you make decisions when our instincts and your recommendations don't align?"
This question reveals how the relationship will actually work when there's productive friction. The best answers acknowledge that disagreement is a normal part of strong agency relationships and describe how the agency typically navigates it — sharing their perspective with conviction, listening to yours, and ultimately respecting your decision-making authority on questions about your own business.
Concerning answers include "we always defer to what the client wants" (which sounds nice but actually means the agency won't push back when you need them to) and "we trust our process" (which sounds principled but actually means the agency won't update their thinking based on your knowledge of your own business). The best agencies are confident enough to push back and humble enough to be persuaded by good arguments.
3. "What would you change about our current marketing if you had complete authority?"
This question tests whether the agency can produce genuine strategic recommendations rather than generic capabilities pitches. The agencies worth working with will have specific, substantive answers grounded in their understanding of your category — they'll identify specific gaps or opportunities they've noticed, with reasoning that demonstrates actual analysis.
Agencies that struggle with this question, who give vague answers, or who deflect to "we'd want to learn more before making recommendations" are revealing that they don't have meaningful strategic thinking to offer. That's important to know before signing a contract.
4. "What's a recent example of strategic work where you got something wrong, and what did you learn from it?"
This question reveals the agency's relationship with learning and improvement. The best agencies can speak openly about engagements that didn't go well, what they learned, and how their approach has evolved as a result. They're comfortable with this kind of vulnerability because they're confident in their overall capability.
Agencies that can't think of an example of being wrong, or who deflect to client-side issues that prevented their good work from succeeding, are revealing limited capacity for self-reflection. Those agencies will repeat the same mistakes on your account because they haven't built the practice of learning from them.
Questions That Reveal Execution Quality
5. "Who specifically will be doing the strategic work on our account, and who will be doing the execution?"
The senior strategist in your sales conversations is rarely the team doing the actual work. This question forces clarity about who will actually deliver your engagement.
Listen for specific names and roles, not vague references to "our team." Listen for evidence that the senior people involved in the sales process will remain involved in the work — not handing off to junior teams once the contract is signed. Listen for honest descriptions of the work distribution, including which elements will be done by more senior versus more junior team members.
The work quality you'll receive depends on who's doing it. An agency that won't be specific about staffing is hiding something you need to know.
Follow-up questions worth asking once you've gotten initial names and roles: How long have these team members been with the agency? What's their background and experience specifically in wellness or aesthetics? Will the people doing the work in months one through three be the same people doing the work in months six through twelve? The answers reveal whether you're getting stable, experienced teams or whether your account will be rotated through whoever has capacity at any given moment.
Some agencies use a "bait and switch" pattern — senior staff present in sales conversations, junior staff doing the actual work after the contract is signed. This pattern isn't unusual, and it's a major source of agency relationships that disappoint after launch. The best protection against this pattern is asking specific staffing questions during evaluation and confirming the answers contractually if necessary. Agencies that resist transparency about staffing are essentially asking you to trust them on the most important quality variable in the engagement — without giving you any basis to verify that trust.
6. "What does a typical week of work look like during the active phase of our engagement?"
This question reveals the actual rhythm and substance of the agency's process. You should hear specific activities — strategy reviews, creative development, content production, campaign optimization, analytics review, client communication. You should hear evidence of structured workflows and consistent processes rather than improvisation.
Vague answers ("we deliver what each client needs") suggest the agency doesn't have repeatable processes — which means the quality of your work will depend more on luck than on systems. Agencies with mature processes can describe them in detail because they live them every week.
7. "How do you handle the gap between what we want to say and what our audience actually responds to?"
This question reveals whether the agency has genuine audience expertise or just executes on client wishes. The best agencies will describe how they bring data, audience research, and category expertise to challenge client assumptions when those assumptions don't match audience reality. They'll talk about specific examples where client instincts and audience response diverged, and how they navigated that.
Agencies that respond with some version of "we focus on what the client wants to communicate" are revealing that they don't bring meaningful audience expertise to the engagement — which means you'll get marketing that reflects your assumptions rather than marketing that actually works with your audience.
8. "Can you show me work where the strategy is visible in the execution, not just the strategy document?"
This question separates agencies whose strategy and execution are integrated from those where the two are disconnected. Ask to see specific examples — not just the brand strategy document, but the website that resulted from it, the ad campaigns that expressed it, the content that reflected it. Look for evidence that the strategic thinking actually informed the work rather than being a separate exercise that got filed away while execution proceeded on autopilot.
If the work and the strategy don't visibly connect — if the strategy document describes one thing and the execution looks like generic agency output — you're looking at an agency that produces strategy and execution as separate functions rather than an integrated practice.
Questions That Reveal Relationship Dynamics
9. "What's the longest client relationship you currently have, and what makes it work?"
The duration of agency-client relationships tells you something important. Agencies with high client churn are usually high-churn for a reason — the work doesn't sustain, the relationships fray, or the agency's interests aren't aligned with their clients' long-term success.
The best agencies have multi-year relationships with multiple clients, and they can describe specifically why those relationships work. Their answers will mention things like alignment around long-term outcomes, productive working dynamics, mutual respect, and consistent delivery. These details matter — they reveal the cultural elements that make long agency relationships possible.
10. "What kinds of clients aren't a good fit for you?"
This question is one of the most diagnostic in the entire evaluation. Agencies that have clear answers — specific descriptions of client types or situations where they don't deliver well — are demonstrating self-awareness and integrity. They've thought carefully about where they add value and where they don't, and they're comfortable telling you honestly.
Agencies that respond with "we work with everyone" or "we can adapt to any situation" are either lying or unaware. Both are concerning. No agency is genuinely a good fit for every client; the ones that claim to be either don't understand themselves or are willing to compromise their actual quality to win business they shouldn't take on. Either way, you don't want to be one of those clients.
The most informative version of this answer comes from agencies that have specific criteria for client fit and can describe both the criteria and the reasoning behind them. They might say something like "we don't work with clients who aren't ready to invest in strategic foundation work, because our approach depends on that foundation existing." Or "we don't work with practices in pre-product-market-fit stages, because our model amplifies what already exists rather than creating it from scratch." Or "we don't take on clients who want to compete on price, because that contradicts the positioning we're built to support." These specific filters reveal an agency that knows itself well enough to be selective — which is the same self-awareness that produces the best work for the clients they do take on.
11. "When did you last fire a client, or part ways with one mid-engagement?"
Following from the previous question, this one reveals whether the agency actually acts on their self-awareness or just talks about it. The best agencies have parted ways with clients who weren't right fits — not maliciously, but because they recognized that the engagement wasn't serving either party. They can describe these situations professionally and explain why ending the engagement was better than continuing it.
Agencies that have never parted ways with a client, especially established agencies, are revealing either that they take any business that comes their way (compromising their selectivity) or that they're not honest about engagements that should have ended sooner. Neither is what you want.
12. "How do you handle the conversation when an engagement isn't producing the results you both hoped for?"
This question reveals the agency's relationship with accountability and adjustment. The best agencies have honest, structured ways of addressing performance issues — not defensive explanations of why their work isn't producing results, but genuine analysis of what's not working and how to fix it. They'll describe specific examples of these conversations and the adjustments they made as a result.
Agencies that struggle with this question, or who attribute disappointing results entirely to client-side factors, are revealing that they don't take meaningful accountability for outcomes. That's a problem when your engagement isn't going well — which happens periodically in even the strongest agency relationships.
Questions That Reveal Category Fit
13. "How many wellness or aesthetic practices have you worked with, and what have you learned from that work?"
This question gets at category expertise concretely. The answer should include specific client work and specific learnings — patterns the agency has observed, approaches they've refined, mistakes they've learned to avoid. The depth of the answer reveals the depth of category expertise.
Be specifically alert to vague answers ("we've worked with several wellness brands") that don't include actual learnings. An agency that has worked with five wellness brands but can't articulate what they've learned hasn't actually built category expertise — they've just worked with similar clients without extracting deeper understanding from the work. That's different from genuine specialization.
The depth and specificity of category learning is one of the most important differentiators between agencies. Genuine specialization shows up as pattern recognition that informs decision-making. The agency will be able to say things like "we've noticed that wellness clients in their forties respond more to X messaging approach than to Y" or "for boutique studios specifically, this channel sequence tends to outperform the alternatives" or "Pilates studios have a specific dynamic with discovery calls that requires this approach." These insights are the substance of category expertise — and they're impossible to fake because they only emerge from actual experience analyzed carefully.
Ask for these kinds of specific insights. Agencies that have them will share them readily. Agencies that don't will struggle to produce them in real time, and that struggle is itself diagnostic about how much category expertise they actually bring to your engagement.
14. "What's specifically different about marketing for premium wellness practices compared to other categories you work in?"
This question tests whether the agency has thought carefully about category-specific dynamics or applies the same approach across industries. The best answers will identify specific differences in buyer psychology, compliance considerations, brand expectations, and competitive dynamics. They'll describe how their approach changes when working with wellness practices versus other categories they serve.
Agencies that struggle with this question, or who describe their approach as essentially the same across categories, are revealing that they're treating wellness like any other industry. That's a problem because wellness isn't like any other industry — and the marketing approaches that work elsewhere often fail here for specific reasons that category-specialized agencies understand.
15. "What's your point of view on something that's currently considered conventional wisdom in wellness marketing?"
This question reveals whether the agency has developed their own thinking about wellness marketing or just executes on category norms. The best answers will identify something — a tactic, a positioning approach, a measurement framework — that they think is widely accepted but actually wrong, with reasoning that demonstrates their genuine analysis of the category.
Agencies that don't have answers to this question, or whose answers are vague platitudes, are revealing that they don't have developed thinking about wellness marketing specifically. They execute on conventional wisdom without questioning it, which means the work you'll receive will be defined by category norms rather than by genuine strategic thinking applied to your situation.
How to Use These Questions
Asked all at once, these questions become an interrogation that no agency will respond to well. The point isn't to grill candidates — it's to surface the information you need to make a good decision.
Distribute these questions across two or three conversations with each finalist. Some are naturally first-conversation questions ("how would you approach the first thirty days?"). Others fit better in deeper conversations once you've established rapport ("when did you last fire a client?"). Let the conversations flow naturally while ensuring you cover the questions that matter most.
Listen carefully to how the questions are answered, not just what's said. The best answers are specific, grounded, and confident. Concerning answers are vague, deflective, or rehearsed. The agencies that consistently give the best answers across these questions are typically the ones worth hiring. The ones that struggle across multiple questions usually struggle for reasons that will surface later in the engagement.
Pay attention to which questions agencies handle well and which they struggle with. Pattern recognition matters. An agency that handles strategic questions well but struggles with execution questions might be strong on thinking but weak on doing. An agency that's strong on execution but struggles with relationship questions might deliver good work but create difficult dynamics. The combination of patterns reveals more than any single answer.
Also pay attention to which questions surprise the agency. Questions that the agency clearly hasn't been asked before — and that they answer thoughtfully rather than defensively — often reveal more than rehearsed answers to common questions. The agencies that engage genuinely with unexpected questions are demonstrating exactly the kind of thoughtful engagement you want in a partner.
Take notes during these conversations, especially on answers that feel either particularly strong or particularly weak. Memory blurs across multiple agency conversations, and your notes become essential for honest comparison later. Specific quotes that surprised you positively or negatively are more useful than your overall impression of who "felt better" — impressions tend to be biased toward whoever you spoke with most recently or who had the best sales presence. Specific evidence from your notes cuts through that bias.
The Meta-Question
There's one final question that's actually the most important, and it's a question you ask yourself rather than the agency: would I genuinely enjoy working with these people over the next two to three years?
The right marketing partnership for a wellness practice is a long-term relationship. You'll spend significant time in meetings, in creative reviews, in strategic discussions, in tough conversations when things aren't working. The agency you choose will have direct influence on your business — and indirect influence on your life, because the marketing partnership is part of your overall work experience.
Working with people who feel right to work with — who you respect, trust, and enjoy as partners — is qualitatively different from working with people who are technically competent but uncomfortable to spend time with. The competence matters. The compatibility matters too. The best engagements typically combine both.
After all the strategic questions, the execution probing, the category fit testing, ask yourself this honest question. The answer often clarifies the decision in ways no other evaluation can. Sometimes the most technically impressive agency isn't the right one because the partnership doesn't feel right. Sometimes a slightly less impressive agency is the right one because the people are exceptional and you'll do your best work together. Both of those instincts are worth honoring.
What Strong Answers Look Like (In Aggregate)
When you've asked all fifteen of these questions across your conversations, the strongest candidates will share several patterns.
Their answers will be specific rather than abstract. They'll reference concrete examples, actual clients (with appropriate confidentiality), real situations they've navigated. The specificity demonstrates that the agency has actually done the work, not just talked about doing it.
Their answers will reveal a coherent philosophy. Across multiple questions, the same underlying approach will be visible. They have a worldview, and it shows up consistently. This coherence is what makes their work distinctive rather than generic.
Their answers will include appropriate honesty about limitations. The strongest agencies are confident enough to acknowledge what they don't do well, what they've learned from mistakes, and which clients aren't a fit. This honesty is itself a positive signal — it suggests an agency you can trust to tell you the truth throughout the engagement.
Their answers will demonstrate genuine category expertise. Their thinking about wellness marketing will be distinct from what a generalist would say. They'll have insights about your specific category that you didn't have before talking to them.
And their answers will feel honest rather than rehearsed. The conversation will have texture and substance, not the polished smoothness of a sales pitch. You'll leave the conversations feeling like you actually learned something — about marketing, about your business, about the agency itself.
When all of those patterns show up together, you're looking at the right kind of partner. The investment in asking the right questions is what makes finding them possible. Practice owners who skip this work often end up disappointed; those who do it thoroughly almost always find partners worth the engagement.
Ready to see proven strategies for premium positioning in health and wellness businesses? Download our Health + Wellness Marketing Report for comprehensive case studies and insights.
Want to discuss positioning your wellness business for luxury clients? Schedule a complimentary consultation to explore strategic approaches for your specific market and goals.
About the Author: The team at Kōvly Studio specializes in helping wellness businesses develop premium brand positioning that attracts high-value clients. Our strategy-first approach ensures your marketing authentically represents your expertise while connecting with clients who value quality over price. Learn more at kovlystudio.com.